Moby-Dick Reviews Archive
Browse all 125 known contemporary reviews of Moby-Dick from 1851–1852, plus key revival-era criticism. The most complete collection online.
🇺🇸
Church Review and Ecclesiastical Register
favorable
“That Melville has genius, wit, mirth, a vigorous, imaginative style, great command of language, and uncommon power of description, is unquestionable.
”
— Volume 4, January 1852
🇺🇸
The Knickerbocker
favorable
“His ocean-pictures are exceedingly graphic. Indeed, his descriptions of taking the whale are a succession of moving pictures; the detail bringing out every point of light and shadow with wonderful effect.
”
— Volume 39, January 1852
🇺🇸
Peterson's Magazine
favorable
“Not an indifferent work, but a very superior one, after all.
”
— Volume 21, January 1852
🇺🇸
Today, a Boston Literary Journal
favorable
“Enough fine and valuable passages in it to amply repay its perusal.
”
— January 10, 1852
🇺🇸
Hunt's Merchant's Magazine and Commercial Review
favorable
“Those who expect to find an agreeable and entertaining volume in this will not be disappointed. In some parts it may be rather diffuse, but as a whole it will be read with gratification.
”
— January 1852
🇺🇸
Graham's Magazine
favorable
“This volume sparkles with the raciest qualities of the author’s voluble and brilliant mind. It has passages of description and narration equal to the best that Melville has written, and its rhetoric revels and riots in scenes of nautical adventure with more than usual glee and gusto.
”
— Edwin Percy Whipple, February 1852
🇺🇸
Godey's Lady's Book
favorable
“A compact volume of upwards of six hundred pages, all about 'the whale,' whalers, and whaling, being itself a perfect literary whale, and worthy of the pen of Herman Melville, whose reputation as an original writer has been established the world over.
”
— February 1852
🇺🇸
Harper's Magazine
favorable
“Quotes the London Atlas as 'one of the most discriminating reviewals we have seen' of Melville's 'greatest effort.'
”
— January 1852
🇺🇸
Harper's Magazine
favorable
“Who knows the horrors of the seas like Herman Melville?
”
— April 1852 (quoting the London Leader)
🇺🇸
Littell's Living Age
favorable
“Reprinted the New York Courier review: 'The author writes with the gusto of true genius.'
”
— Volume 32, January 17, 1852
🇦
Toronto Globe
favorable
“A favorable notice of Moby-Dick appeared in this Canadian newspaper.
”
— November 29, 1851
🇺🇸
Boston Evening Transcript
favorable
“We very cordially welcome Mr. Melville back to the field, where he has won so many laurels. He will be at home among the whalers, and his book will be eagerly sought for by those who remember the first two nautical romances from his pen.
”
— November 12, 1851
🎯 Stop Struggling. Start Understanding.
The annotated edition of Moby-Dick gives you everything you need to finally get Melville's masterpiece:
- ✅ Complete, unabridged text — every word of the original 1851 edition
- ✅ Hundreds of explanatory footnotes — no more Googling every other page
- ✅ Historical context — the Essex disaster, Nantucket whaling, Melville's life
- ✅ Literary analysis — chapter-by-chapter commentary on themes and symbols
- ✅ Victorian vocabulary — obsolete words and nautical terms defined inline
- ✅ Biblical & literary references — every allusion traced to its source